ABOUT THIS BLOG

News, analysis, feature stories, random thoughts... if it's about college basketball, either in season or during the summer doldrums, you'll find it in Beyond the Arc.

Mike Miller

Mike Miller has been NBCSports.com's college basketball editor since 2003. It's a position he relishes; no wonder considering he transferred to Kansas to watch Paul Pierce play. Most of his favorite sports memories involve college hoops, usually during March, when every waking moment is spent thinking about March Madness.



Kentucky musings, coaching moves and more

Posted: Friday, May 09, 2008 5:12 PM
Filed Under:

The Friday links, for your clicking pleasure.

May as well start with Kentucky hoops.

First saw this on the Big Lead, then spent the rest of my morning searching the Web for other info on Wildcats fans taking issue with longtime Lexington Herald-Leader reporter Jerry Tipton and his story on Billy Gillispie getting a verbal commitment from an 8th grader. Seriously, there was a lot of reading to do. A lot. (Off topic, I like A Sea of Blue’s redesign. Sharp.)

I kicked around a few ideas, wrote a few grafs, but decided I couldn’t settle on what I really wanted to say. Maybe I need more caffeine.

The gist: I like Tipton’s work. He’s a solid reporter (he and Gary Bedore at the Lawrence Journal-World may be the best all-hoops reporters covering teams with this kind of devout fan base) and covering a team like Kentucky isn’t easy. The hours are brutal and the payoff isn’t great, especially when a story angers the fan base.

But this is now just part of the game for reporters. Fans will say what fans want, whether it’s through online comments, calling radio shows or writing letters to newspapers. Whenever something’s written about the ‘Cats, UK fans find it and let you know what they think. It’s the good/bad part of his job. Every Kentucky fan reads his stuff, but they can be an instant critic.

For someone like Tipton, that can be a losing battle if the public perception is that he writes negative stories about Kentucky. How does one compete against that without losing all objectivity?

He can’t. But he can be objective and fair. Though it seems like he’s been that way all along.

MAIN PAGE

Email this EMAIL THIS

Comments

Jerry Tipton isn't necessarily anti-UK, but darn if he's not a big-time pessimist.  He's a real half-empty kind of guy, or at least his material comes across that way.  He does seem an ill fit for a beat that almost demands an upbeat attitude.
Thanks for the link and the nice comment on ASoB's redesign.  That's actually a network-wide upgrade for (very soon to be) all SB Nation network blogs.  We love it.  Glad you like it as well.

On the whole Tipton thing, I can't blame UK fans for being angry at some of the questions he is asking.  I do think the whole connection between Gillispie's practice routine and the rash of injuries we had is unworthy of a question to new recruits.  But that is surely a judgment call, and Jerry Tipton is entitled to make it whether I agree or not.

Tipton tends to be a "glass half empty" kind of guy, maybe to protect the perception that he is not in the tank for UK -- and he most assuredly isn't.  But the idea that he is somehow conspiring to harm UK just doesn't have the necessary support in the record, and I just don't believe it.

But if fans want to pull their subscriptions based on the fact they think Tipton is a jerk, I could care less.  That's their right -- they pay their money, and if they are not satisfied with not getting more propaganda and less criticism, they have a perfect right to do so.  Does it seem over the top to me?  

Yeah.  But never forget the derivation of the word "Fan."
What you missed in your investigation were the types of questions Tipton was asking UK recruit's parents and how uncomfortable they felt due to Tipton.  He is free to his opinions and to do the work of a journalist, but when you do what he has done, you've overstepped your bounds as a journalist and any "objectivity" that you credit him for.


SEND A COMMENT

PLEASE READ: All comments must be approved before appearing in the thread; time and space constraints prevent all comments from appearing. We will only approve comments that are directly related to the blog, use appropriate language and are not attacking the comments of others.

Message (please, no HTML tags. Web addresses will be hyperlinked):

Syndicate This Site

Add Beyond the Arc to your news reader:
live.com xml
myyahoo msn
bloglines newsgator
google