ABOUT THIS BLOG

News, analysis, feature stories, random thoughts... if it's about college basketball, either in season or during the summer doldrums, you'll find it in Beyond the Arc.

Mike Miller

Mike Miller has been msnbc.com's college basketball editor since 2003. It's a position he relishes; no wonder considering he transferred to Kansas to watch Paul Pierce play. Most of his favorite sports memories involve college hoops, usually during March, when every waking moment is spent thinking about March Madness.



The greatest programs: No. 13, Villanova

Posted: Tuesday, July 15, 2008 10:02 AM
Filed Under:

Any mention of Villanova basketball always circles back to the 1985 national champions. It just can’t be helped.

That Wildcats team pulled off one of college hoops’ most memorable upsets, beating defending national champion Georgetown, a squad analysts had been trying to place among the all-time greats. The ‘Cats made 90 percent of their field-goal attempts in the second half, and shot nearly 80 percent for the game, a remarkable feat on the national stage.

It could go on and on (in fact, more later). But that’s the point. Villanova has more hoops lore than just than ’85 team.

  • ‘Nova will hit 1,500 wins next season, placing it ahead of UConn and Michigan State, while its .634 win percentage is higher than Cincinnati and Georgetown.
  • The Wildcats’ 29 NCAA tourney berths are 10th most all-time.
  • They’ve won more than 60 percent of their games in the Big Dance, better than Illinois and Arkansas.
  • Villanova’s second only to St. John’s in total NIT wins and it’s produced a healthy number of NBA players.

The ‘Cats are another example of sustained excellence (they’re one of two programs to play in the Big Dance in each decade) and recent success to pair with a strong tradition. Add it up, and Villanova is No. 13 on the list of the greatest college basketball programs.

So, instead of focusing only on that ’85 team, let’s start at the beginning. After all, ‘Nova may have one of the biggest NCAA tourney wins, but it also has the first.

Under coach Al Severance (whose 413 wins are the most in school history), the Wildcats snagged that first win (it was against Brown), played in four NCAA tourneys, helped establish Philadelphia’s Big Five tradition in 1955 (and played some classic games against former Palestra co-habitant St. Joe’s in the process) and featured the best player to ever put on a Wildcats uniform, Philly native Paul Arizin.

Arizin, who died in 2006 at the age of 78, played for La Salle High School in Philly, served in the Marine Corps and enrolled at ‘Nova in 1946. The story goes that Severance saw the 6-foot-4 Arizin shooting jumpers in the gym and promptly got him on the team.

Is the story true? Who knows? What matters is that Arizin was amazing. He torched Navy for 85 points in 1949 – still a Philly-area record – and was revolutionary with his one-handed jump shot, a skill few players featured then.

"It came by accident," Arizin would recall many years later in an interview with The Christian Science Monitior. "Some of our games were played on dance floors. It became quite slippery. When I tried to hook, my feet would go out from under me, so I jumped. I was always a good jumper. My feet weren't on the floor, so I didn't have to worry about slipping. The more I did it, the better I became. Before I knew it, practically all of my shots were jump shots."

After Arizin, Villanova continued to produce good players, notably Larry Hennessy and Bob Schafer. And ‘Nova continued its winning ways under new coach Jack Kraft, who guided the team to its second Final Four berth in 1971 behind the brilliant play of three-time All-American Howard Porter.

‘Nova’s “Iron Men” finished the season 27-9, crushed a previously unbeaten Penn team 90-47 in the NCAA tourney and gave UCLA a scare in the championship game, losing 68-62 – the closest any team came to dethroning the Bruins during their seven-year title run. The “mesmerizing” Porter was named the tourney’s most outstanding player, a rare feat for a player from the runner-up.

Yet it wasn’t a happy ending. Porter had signed a contract with the ABA’s Pittsburgh Condors during his senior year. That rules violation cost Porter his MOP and the NCAA vacated ‘Nova’s Final Four appearance.

(Porter later drifted into a failed NBA career and drug use, but by ’89 he had cleaned himself up. When he died from injuries sustained during a beating in Minneapolis, memories of Porter detailed the life of a supremely gifted player who never did quite recover from that error in his senior year.)

Rollie Massimino took over the program in 1973, started to thrive in the late ‘70s and early ‘80s (notably with cool Rory Sparrow at the helm). His teams won five Big East regular-season titles, thriving during the league’s initial years.

But nothing ever came close to ’85.

Seeded eighth in the first year of the NCAA tournament’s expansion to 64 teams, the Wildcats beat Dayton (at Dayton), stunned top-seeded Michigan, scooted past Maryland and No. 2 seed UNC before surprising Memphis State in the Final Four.

With Big East rival Georgetown looming in the championship, Massimino’s squad had already lost two close games to the Hoyas, but were “nearly perfect” in their 66-64 victory. (For perspective, the Hoyas were no slouches themselves. They made 55 percent of their 53 field-goal attempts, hardly a poor performance.)

The game turned Massimino into a ‘Nova icon, made Final Four MOP Ed Pinckney into an NBA lottery pick (talking about the win “never gets old” for him) and established the Wildcats as one of the memorable hoops underdogs.

(For a fabulous recap on that season and what followed, click here.)

Under Steve Lappas and current coach Jay Wright, Villanova has been one of the consistent title contenders (Big East player of the year Kerry Kittles was a personal fave), most recently with the 2005-06 squad that featured a three-guard attack of Randy Foye, Allan Ray and Kyle Lowry that was ousted in the Elite Eight by eventual national champ Florida.

With star guard Scottie Reynolds (no scoring slouch himself), ‘Nova is the premier hoops destination in Philly, a hoops hotbed all its own. (Indeed, if Massimino had paid more attention to the Philly prep players, he might still be at ‘Nova).

Phillys a town that loves its pro teams, but Villanova is a college where the rules don’t apply, says Soft Pretzel Logic’s Jonathan Tannenwald. Credit for that goes to Wright, a natty dresser and even better coach.

“Kids want to play in that kind of environment,” Tanenwald says.

And that kind of environment makes for great hoops.

Coming next week: No. 12 on the list of greatest programs.

No. 14: Illinois.

No. 15: Michigan State.

No. 16: Georgetown.

No. 17: Arkansas.

No. 18: Ohio State.

No. 19: St. John's.

No. 20: UNLV.

No. 21: Texas.

No. 22: Notre Dame.

No. 23: Temple.

No. 24: Oklahoma.

No. 25: N.C. State. 

MAIN PAGE

Email this EMAIL THIS

Comments

I think 'Nova Nation will approve a #13 ranking.

In recent years, Villanova is 1 of 5 programs to make the Sweet 16 in 3 of the past 4 years (WVU, Memphis, UNC, and UCLA are the others).
Alright, I will complain first.  How in the hell is Villanova ranked ahead of Georgetown, Michigan State, Oklahoma State, Ohio State, and Arkansas.  Those schools have either more titles, the same number of titles and more FF's, or more titles and FF's.  Villanova is a worthy top 25 mention, but they should never sniff the top 15 on a list like this.  The NIT I think is weighing too heavily in your formula and you should reconsider this.  Mike, you are the man for attempting this especially during a dead period to help us hoops junkies out but you definitely need me to help you reform your list next summer!
Villanova deserves to be there.  One has to look at the entire history.  We're talking 60 years.  Georgetown was nothing before John Thompson.  Villanova was in the first Final 4.  So while an argument can be made for any of the schools mentioned by Adam, arguments which are just as compelling can be made for Nova.

Nova is not Top 5 or even Top 10, but desrve to be mentioned in the top 15 or so.
I agree the NIT is too much weight.  It basically says you are the 65th (66th now) best team in the country that year as you were not good enough that season to make the tournament.  Although nice to win, I don't think it should factor in that much.
'Cats have more NCAA bids than Georgetown, MSU, either OSU and Arkansas and more NCAA wins than all those schools except Georgetown (one more).  Villanova also has more NCAA wins and bids than UCONN, Cin and Arizona who I assume will be higher on this list. They also have been to 10 regional finals. Taking all of Mike's parameters into consideration, 'Cats are about where they should be.
Villanova definately belongs right where they are. Try to remember "all time" does not mean the last 20 years of recent  TV memory.  Couse I am a Nova grad and a little biased
One might want to take into account that many of Villanova's NIT accomplishments came at a time when the NIT was "THE" tournament. Yes the later NIT Championship might carry too much weight, but Nova's overall NIT successes are important. Not to mention that they've made something like eleven Elite Eights in the modern NCAA.
Villanova keeps moving to the top of the charts-- academically and athletically. Go 'Cats!
Ridiculous placement. You hit Ohio St. because of its violation but not 'Nova for theirs. Sure, the 'Cats have had some success in recent NCAAs (and were completely hosed by the refs in the Elite 8 against UNC) and have long-term consistency, but, unlike St. John's, they never won the NIT while it mattered; most of their NIT wins were in the past 30 years and at home when they meant little to nothing. For that matter, how impressive is being in the first Final Four when it only took one victory to get there? There can be no denying that their win over GU is iconic in sports history, but there hasn't ever been an era that the 'Cats have challenged for dominance. To be honest, I was a little shocked not to see 'Nova in the 20-30/ORV range, but that was because I thought you might have overlooked them, not over-rated them! Now it looks like you have overlooked Utah, unless you are going to leave out one of Syracuse, Cincinnati, Arizona, Michigan or UConn (well, maybe being good for the last 20 years with little to show before that will keep them off the list despite their two titles, just like Florida). We'll see...
NCAA Appearances:

1 Kentucky 50

2 UCLA 42

3 North Carolina 40

4 Kansas 37

5 Indiana 35

6 Louisville 34

7 Duke 32

8 Syracuse 31

9 Arkansas  29
Notre Dame 29
Villanova 29

12  Connecticut 28

13 Illinois 27
St Johns 27
Arizona 27

SWEET 16 or Better
1 Kentucky 41

2  UCLA 32

3  North Carolina  29

4  Kansas 26

5  Duke 23
Louisville 23

7 Indiana  20

8 Syracuse 17
 Utah 17
 Villanova  17



SEND A COMMENT

PLEASE READ: All comments must be approved before appearing in the thread; time and space constraints prevent all comments from appearing. We will only approve comments that are directly related to the blog, use appropriate language and are not attacking the comments of others.

Message (please, no HTML tags. Web addresses will be hyperlinked):

Syndicate This Site

Add Beyond the Arc to your news reader:
live.com xml
myyahoo msn
bloglines newsgator
google